I hate to say it, but summer is beginning to wind down. Even more disturbing for killer whale observers is an awareness that Puget Sound’s iconic orcas have pretty much avoided Puget Sound altogether this year.
The patterns of travel and even the social structure of the endangered Southern Resident killer whales have been disrupted the past several years, and this year is the worst ever, according to Ken Balcomb of the Center for Whale Research, who has been keeping track of these whales for the past 40 years.
For decades, we could expect all three pods of Southern Residents to show up in June, if not before. They would mingle and socialize and generally remain through the summer in the San Juan Islands, feasting on the chinook salmon that migrate to Canada’s Fraser River.
Photo: Ken Balcomb, Center for Whale Research
In recent years, the large orca pods have broken into smaller groups of whales that keep coming and going, as if searching for scattered schools of salmon. This year, the Southern Residents have made few appearances in Puget Sound, barely enough for Ken to complete his annual census report to the federal government.
The latest official count is 77 orcas among the three pods. That reflects the death of K-13, a 45-year old female named Skagit. Ken did not announce her passing, mainly because it is based on limited encounters. Ken tells me that K-13 was the only whale missing during an encounter with her close relatives in February in Puget Sound and then later off the coast.
Normally, he would like to have more encounters before declaring a missing animal deceased, but Skagit has always been a central figure in her family group, which sometimes traveled separately from the rest of K pod.
Under the original protocols for counting whales, one would wait a year before listing the death, Ken told me, but now people are keeping track of the current population as orcas are born and die. His official census count is made on July 1, and he was confident that the missing Skagit would not turn up later.
K-13 was the mother of four offspring: K-20, a 31-year-old female named Spock; K-25, a 26-year-old male named Scoter; K-27, a 23-year-old female named Deadhead; and K-34, a 16-year-old male named Cali. Skagit was the grandmother to Spock’s 13-year-old calf, K-38 or Comet, and to Deadhead’s 6-year-old calf, K-44 or Ripple.
The question now is how the remaining whales in the family group will respond. In a matriarchal society, groups are led by elder females whose extended family generally stays with them for life. Will one of Skagit’s female offspring assume the leadership role? Will the family group remain as independent as it has been in the past?
“It’s a big question,” said Brad Hanson of NOAA’s Northwest Fisheries Science Center. “These animals are so long-lived. How do you sort out the loss of an animal like J-2, who has had a leadership role for so many years? Do they keep doing the same thing, or do they do something different?”
J-2, known as “Granny” was estimated to be more than 100 years old when she died last year. The oldest whale among the Southern Residents, she was known as the leader of the clans. Check out these posts in Water Ways:
- Granny, a killer whale unlike any other, stayed graceful to the end
- Granny, the orca, was seen in poor condition before her death
- Thoughts run to an orca called Granny and her clan of five generations
The effect of losing Skagit’s leadership is hard to measure, but it comes on top of the fragmenting social structure among the Southern Residents. As the remaining orcas seem to be wandering around in search of food, we are likely to see fewer births and more deaths.
Studies have shown a strong correlation between births and prey availability, Ken told me, and the absence of the orcas alone is an indicator that fewer salmon are coming through the San Juan Islands. Whether the whales are finding adequate salmon runs somewhere else is hard to say, because nobody really knows where they are.
“I think they are out there intercepting whatever runs are coming down from the Gulf of Alaska,” Ken said. “Most of the salmon up there are destined for down here. They (the whales) are tough, and they will survive if they can.”
While the fish-eating Southern Residents have been absent from Puget Sound, the seal-eating transient killer whales are making themselves at home in local waters. It appears there is no shortage of seals, sea lions and harbor porpoises for them to eat, and transients are being spotted more often by people on shore and in boats.
Meanwhile, the Southern Residents typically head into Central and South Puget Sound to hunt for chum salmon during September, sometimes October. Although the migrating chum return to hundreds of streams all over Puget Sound, the orcas have become less predictable in their travels during the fall as well as the summer.
“I am hoping that the fall chum runs are strong and the whales will come in,” Ken said, “but I’m not holding my breath.”
The total count of 77 Southern Resident killer whales consists of 24 whales in J pod, 18 whales in K pod and 35 whales in L pod. Those numbers do not include Lolita, who was captured in Puget Sound as a calf and still lives in Miami Seaquarium in Florida.
Please remove the dams from the Snake river
There needs to be a broader inquiry into including ocean cessium and various other radioactive pollution that has travelled across the Pacific and more planned to be released. Toxicity is a hormone and endocrine interrupter, not to mention just dying from exposure. Start testing the salmon, the water quality, the military testing, etc. All inclusive overall science.
Another untimely loss for the southern residents, and another reason to be reminded that there are three reasons they are endangered: lack of salmon, toxin accumulations, and stress and noise from boats – not one of these things, but all.
Vessel impacts make it harder southern residents to forage, hunt, and communicate with each other. When the whales are stressed or underweight, toxins may be released from their blubber into their bloodstream, making them more susceptible to disease.
Restoring salmon runs is an important step to their recovery. Reducing boat noise and toxin inputs are also things that we can each and all do something about, now.
While the whales disappear before our eyes, there are more whale-watching boats than ever, operating year-round, and throughout the orcas’ range. So long as the financial needs of this industry and the organizations they support are put ahead of the whales’ very right to exist, the whales are doomed.
Fifteen years ago, we worked together as agencies, organizations and countries to return a single orca, Springer, to her pod. Springer is home and thriving because we learned how to work together and above all, because we put her best interest first.
Hand-wringing won’t save the southern residents. We need a clear-eyed understanding of what the issues are, and shared determination to address them.
I don’t know what sustainable whale-watching looks like for the southern residents, but the status quo is not working. Perhaps the whales will return to the Salish Sea when they have more acoustic space to forage, rest and live their lives.
one word: Fukushima