I thought I’d take a moment to provide at least some quick
answers to a few of the questions that appeared following the story
and the first blog entry on this matter.
Q: I sure do not remember ever seeing any tribal fisherman
fishing there , and I have lived here for over 40 years.
A: I can’t answer whether tribal members have ever fished there,
but the tribe does have the right to do so as part of its “usual
and accustomed” fishing area. Leonard Forsman spoke of the tribe’s
“future rights” in his conversation with me. It may be a lame
example, but it’s similar to me having the right to drive on roads
in Mississippi. You can’t take away that right from me solely
because I’ve never been there.
Q: Hey Steve, It would have been nice if
you mentioned the 570 foot dock the tribe is building that is in
the middle of a much larger fish run than that of the Bremerton
dock.
A: I believe the actual length of the Suquamish dock is 526
feet. I did discuss it with the city and with the tribe and the
dock discussion will be part of a later story. However, I still
need to educate myself more about it, because I’m not convinced
that it’s a fair criticism of the tribe. The boardwalk is six times
as long and runs parallel to the shoreline. Plus, it’s a brand new
feature, whereas the dock has been explained to me as replacing an
old unusable 400-foot pier. On the other hand, I don’t think the
526-feet is the extent of the new dock and I’m not sure the old
pier had near the recent impact the new dock will have. That’s why
I’ve said I need to educate myself more on the dock before
addressing it at length in a story. It’s worth bringing up
generally.
Q: I am just trying to understand how it makes sense to put
a sewer line OVER the water?
A: This information was clarified in the story to reflect more
accurately that the sewer line would still run along the shoreline,
but the boardwalk would have offshoots that would allow Public
Works crews to access the sewer line.
Q: Bremerton should have thought through their project
before it got to this stage. That means consultations with other
agencies including tribes.
A: This was addressed in another blog entry that included
Forsman’s letter. It’s clear to me that this is an important issue
to people on both sides, because people on both sides have
complained to me about it. Because the information wasn’t included
in the story, some have concluded that the tribe only recently
raised its objections. The tribe and the city were in conversations
about this, and I get this from both camps, for about two years.
The written objection was penned earlier this year, but Forsman
said the city knew about the objections at least a year ago. I
thought that including the information about some of the proposals
the city had made to solve the tribe’s issues would make it clear
that this is not new to those involved, but it’s clear now I should
have spelled that out more.
Q: Why has no one asked where the City of Bremerton got the
million plus dollars to spend on planning the boardwalk?
A: The story included, “Williams said the city estimates the
cost to be around $24.6 million, of which the city has already
raised about $14.3 million from property sales and state grants.” I
believe there has been other city funds applied. Further in the
question though the writer asks, “How can the City justify having
already spent this much of YOUR tax dollars if the boardwalk is not
going to get approved?” Well, the easy answer is the city assumed
it could create a project that would get approved. Sometimes
governments design things that don’t pan out. Zoning changes get
nixed in court sometimes. That costs taxpayers money, too, but
generally it’s taxpayers who file suit. Additionally, this project
isn’t dead yet.
Q: No one seems to have pointed out another obvious
question- why didn’t the tribe object to the bremerton marina on
the same grounds???
A: The Port of Bremerton did have to work with the tribe on the
marina and paid some money and built some elements based on
concerns. Many times there are offsite remedies provided in
response to proposals. The city and the tribe have to find what
those could be, and might never find a common ground. If not, the
city could apply, presumably get denied, then appeal.