Andrew Binion writes:
A story in the
Seattle P-I earlier this week sounded the cry over the
shuttering of community college newspapers, and the doom that
spells for a democratic society.
But one such student-run paper that enjoys high student
interest, support from administrators and dedication from staffers
is The Olympian, the
twice-a-month paper with a circulation of 2,000 that is of, by and
for students of Olympic College. The paper also has an online
edition. Editors and advisers from The Olympian, an hour-long ferry
ride from downtown Seattle, were not mentioned in the story.
“Fortunately, here we are doing well,” said Michael Prince,
journalism instructor and adviser to the Olympian. Prince arrived
at the school in 2006. Prior to that the school did not have a
full-time journalism guru.
“They (administrators) very easily could have let it go away,
but they committed to it,” he said.
The Olympian currently has five paid staff members, and may add
one or two more in the coming weeks. Additionally the paper has
about a dozen contributors.
The thinking goes, if community college students aren’t pounding
the beats during their first two years of post-secondary education,
they won’t be in shape to work for their university daily – such as
the Daily Evergreen at
WSU or The Daily at
UW. And each step they take toward professional journalism they
will shamble behind those who started cutting their teeth as a
college freshman.
And if journalists aren’t properly broiled and salted at their
university papers, they won’t be able to do “real” reporting when
they graduate and try to set up a kiosk in the marketplace of
ideas. Then we’ll have chaos, dogs and cats living together,
etc.
As P-I reporter Amy Rolph points out, several Western Washington
community college papers have been petering away, because, as Rolph
put it, “the undeniable fact that can’t be trumped. … Nobody’s
reading anymore.”
(By the way, this is not a slam on Rolph. Her story was
well-written, interesting and important. It’s just that the good
work of The Olympian was not mentioned among other papers not doing
so well.)
The story listed community college papers from Tacoma to North
Seattle that have stalled and featured reader quotes and comments
of righteous indignants upset that amateur publications are so
amateurish.
It’s a simple answer, and tempting to believe, that people are
just stupider.
Prince said the success of The Olympian has less to do with
literacy than with administrators hiring a full-time journalism
instructor/adviser and staying out of decision-making. As noted in
the story, schools without vibrant papers appear to have
administrators who are, at best, indifferent.
Plus, Bremerton is separated from Pugetopolis by
jellyfish-infested Puget Sound creating an alcove that generally
isn’t represented by any other paper. Except (ahem) for the Sun.
Some Kitsap students, however, attend Seattle Central Community
College – Broadway High to us alumni.
An illustrative example of the importance of The Olympian to the
community can be seen in a
protest April 2007, where a considerably-large group of
students took exception to a full-page ad from a local strip club
fishing for fresh bodies to don fishnets. The students protested
outside the offices, called out the paper’s editor and demanded
administrators stop the ad, which featured young women
three-quarters unclad.
The college’s board responded by approving a resolution
disagreeing with the decision and left it at that.
But that process, 1) the publishing of the ad, which required
staffers to make a very serious
decisions 2) the objections of students who organized
opposition to the ad and 3) the powers-that-be respecting the
paper’s free speech rights, showed that not only is The Olympian
doing well, it is helping to foster a sense of community, something
that can be woefully lacking from the community college
experience.