The great Bainbridge pudding heist was featured on a recent airing of the Late Show with David Letterman.

The Bainbridge Islander blotter item was included in a funny news stories segment, along with mentions of a New Mexico woman who used a horn to rid her stove of an evil spirit and a car that was reported stolen in Minnesota but was later found buried under snow – right where the owner left it.

The fact that the stolen Bainbridge pudding was sugar-free drew Letterman’s attention.

“The CSI people would take that tidbit and solve the whole thing,” he said.

You can see the entire show here. Skip ahead to the 29-minute mark to hear the Bainbridge bit.