Analyzing the Seahawks Draft: James Carpenter vs. Gabe Carimi and Derek Sherrod
Friday, April 29th, 2011With the #25 pick in the first round of the NFL draft, the Seahawks selected James Carpenter, an Offensive Guard from Alabama. This was somewhat of a surprise pick, as Carpenter was projected to go some time in the mid second round. Word ’round the camp fire is that the Hawks were trying until the last few seconds to trade that pick and move down, where they would get an extra pick and would still be able to draft Carpenter.
In picking JC at #25, they passed on a bigger and seemingly more physical player in Gabe Carimi, Offensive Tackle from Wisconsin. They also passed on Derek Sherrod, Offensive Tackle from Mississippi State. Here is a look at all of their NFL Combine profiles (information courtesy of NFL.com):

-
Height: 6’4″
-
Weight: 321 lbs.
-
Arm Length: 34 in.
-
Hand Size: 9 3/4 in.
-
College: Alabama
-
Conference: SEC
-
Position: OL
Strengths:
Carpenter is a highly-durable player who has been able to stay on the field during his career. Has the height and build you look for at the offensive tackle position. Does a good job in pass protection against the speed and bull rush. Possesses the athletic ability to get to the second level when run blocking.
Weaknesses:
Can be beat by good counter moves in pass protection. Will occasionally struggle against defensive line stunts and elaborate blitz packages. Does not consistently drive defenders off the line of scrimmage in the downhill running game. Would benefit from playing with a little more fire.

-
Height: 6’7″
-
Weight: 314 lbs.
-
Arm Length: 35 in.
-
Hand Size: 10 3/8 in.
-
College: Wisconsin
-
Conference: Big 10
-
Position: OL
Strengths:
Carimi is a massive tackle that plays mean and looks to dominate opponents. Heady player that recognizes blitzes and adjusts quickly. Delivers a powerful punch and effectively locks out his arms to push rushers past the pocket in pass protection. Moves well for a big man and smothers defenders in the running game.
Weaknesses:
Does not sink his hips well and struggles to maintain leverage which makes him vulnerable to shorter defensive ends. Footwork is a bit sloppy at times in pass protection which allows defenders to get to the edge. Not fluid enough to consistently make blocks in space.
The point of this post is to come back and analyze the success of each player at a later date. It will be interesting to see how accurate the Hawks’ crystal ball is. This way, we can go back in hind sight and critique. The Seahawks obviously saw something they really liked in Carpenter, who is shorter but heavier than Carimi.

-
Height: 6’5″
-
Weight: 321 lbs.
-
Arm Length: 35 3/8 in.
-
Hand Size: 11 in.
-
College: Mississippi St.
-
Conference: SEC
-
Position: OL
Strengths
Sherrod possesses a nice combination of height and mobility. Gets set quickly and can push rushers past the pocket using his length and reach. Uses good positioning to wall-off defenders when run blocking. Has enough athleticism to get out and block in space. Effective when combo blocking.
Weaknesses
Needs to add bulk to his frame. Susceptible to the bull rush and violent moves. Also struggles at times against stunts and twists and can be baited out of position. Not a road-graded. Won’t get too much movement off the line. Doesn’t play with a lot of nastiness.
–
Here’s what I think the Seahawks were thinking: JC played in the SEC, which has been unquestionably the best conference in NCAA D1 over the last few years. He has therefore experienced some of the most ferocious D Linemen in college football. Also, his lower center of gravity allows him to play center in addition to right tackle or guard. By the way, all of this means Sean Locklear is gone as an unrestricted free agent.
If you read the last sentence under ‘weaknesses’ for Sherrod, you’ll see why the Hawks didn’t select him. “Doesn’t play with a lot of nastiness” is a deal breaker and a good reflection of the team’s philosophy.
I’m torn on this issue, but I think I’ll put my trust in the Coach Carroll and the Seahawks management. They’ve obviously got a plan, which seems to be right in line with my ideal Seahawks draft: building a foundation in the offensive line. In rounds 4-5, I’d expect to see us get some D linemen and cornerbacks (nothing undersized, thank you).










An insider's take on Seattle sports and other miscellaneous happenings, written by Northwest sports fan Chadrick Ashby.

Scripps Interactive Newspapers Group
Recent Comments